Categories >> Politics and Latest News >> Apartheid: In the 21st century >> Economics >> Injustice >> Business >>

by: Hagai Bennathan - posted (or last updated): 8th June 2009

Apartheid: In the 21st century

Occupation: Electrical Electronics Engineer for a consumer electronics company

Age: 28
Last Login: Yesterday
Location: Colorado Springs, Colorado
" Together, we can make a difference and forever be happy we did." Hagai

It has been a few years since the publication of Jimmy Carter's book "Palestine: Peace Not Apartheid," which was met with a well-orchestrated and sustained campaign of Israeli disinformation and condemnation of President Carter. For simply describing, in detail, Israeli policies that were consistent with apartheid, the former president and 2002 recipient of the Nobel Peace Prize was labeled an anti-Semite.

South African anti-apartheid activists Bishop Desmond Tutu, Blade Nzimande and John Dugard also identified apartheid in Israeli practices toward Palestinians in the occupied territories and described the privilege of one group over another, detention without trial, control of movement through checkpoints and the wall, and deportation as undisputable apartheid by Israel and noted that the imposed practices are much worse than the apartheid they experience themselves in South Africa that ended in 1990.

At a peace rally, in early June 2009 in Washington D.C., they described a number of cases where Israel has used fully armed F-16 fighter jets and Apache helicopter gunships in residential areas. There have been countless numbers of documented accounts of home demolitions, arrests of families of supposedly suspected "militants" with no trial and no records of arrests, and segregation of roads to separate access for Jewish settlers at the expense of the indigenous population.

A European journalist covering the settlers of Kiryat Arba near Hebron on Dheisheh refugee camp, described the attack against the village by settlers and the Israeli military. She commented that prior to seeing the event with her own eyes, she never would have believed anyone describing this level of brutality by the Israeli soldiers and the fully armed Jewish settlers. Instead of stopping settlers from shooting at unarmed Palestinian population, Israeli Army was assisting them in their attack against Palestinians.

The photographs of both Israeli army and the Jewish settlers, armed to the teeth, was undeniable and the faces of the Israeli settlers was something awful, brutal and that of an angry mob with one goal in mind: to kill Palestinians or throw them out of their lands and take over their homes. The large photographs clearly showing the fanatical mob was very graphical and forced most people at the peace rally to cover the eyes of their own children accompanying them.

At the rally, a Palestinian mother started describing her childhood:

When I was a small child we had nothing better to do other than sit around and listen to our elderly talk. They used to sit and talk about their daily life in occupied Palestine and as children we would sit and listen to their stories and their pain. When they described their suffering, quickly it was also our pain. They talked so often of their daily life describing things they had seen as children and they would tell us how they grew up knowing their family lost everything because of the Israelis and the U.S. support in both military, economic, and Veto support at UN. That the reason for all our misery and the terrible conditions in which we all live in are the Israelis. We were all refugees who lost everything. We would sit and hear people taking about the house they were forced to leave behind, or the land they had just harvested before settlers taking over with guns, or the fruit fields they so much loved and cherished but were taken from them, or worse, the stories of their beloved ones killed by the Jewish settlers or the Israeli military raiding Palestinian towns and villages. As children we also saw for ourselves the Israeli occupation and what occupation was doing to us, and see Israel taking everything from us and gave us nothing but suffering and humiliation. The experiences that our elderly shared with us was what we were witnessing as children ourselves. Palestinians have been accused, unjustly, of all sorts of incitement, through the American and Israeli media. These accusations are based on the lies and fabrications of the Israeli and U.S. governments with the help of propaganda-style studies funded by Jewish organizations such as The American Enterprise Institute, the Heritage Foundation, and various members of the Council for Foreign Relations - and the biggest of all - the American-Israeli Public Affairs Committee.

Within Israel itself, state policies explicitly privilege Jewish citizens over Muslim and Christian citizens and as such are reminiscent of the Jim Crow south. In a December 2006 poll, 50 percent of Israeli Jews expressed the wish that the state encourage Palestinian citizens to leave. This is indeed ethnic cleansing wishes of the people of Israel and delivered by the apartheid occupying forces of Israel.

It makes me very sad to contemplate the assistance given to the occupation of Palestine by Israel and the indifference shown by Western governments. At a later time in future, our children will look back and view this injustice the same way we now see the era of slavery in U.S. and segregation policies of our own government. It further saddens me to realize that this will never be discussed or debated in the Jewish owned Western mainstream media. I still believe that if more people actually understood what is happening that it might be possible to curtail unconditional help for the state of Israel. Given their penetration of the western media and political systems, however, this is unlikely, to say the least.

Israel's apartheid and exclusivist policies must be replaced by equal citizen rights irrespective of race, religion, ethnicity and gender.

There is no freedom on earth or in any star for those who deny freedom to others.

ELBERT HUBBARD (1856-1915)

I know many Jews will be angry with my post here and believe that I should be fighting the cause of Israel, the country that I served all my life and the country that served my interests by depriving others of their rights which has allowed me to go to college and be educated.

But can we not have a world where there is justice for all? Must I support those that have done wrong to others, and still continue to do wrong, just because they have done good to me? And what is good ... having more opportunities because others have been deprived of their rights? I should be proud of that as an Israeli?

Even being born in Israel and having lived there and served in the military is not enough for me to have my own objective opinion without being labeled a self-hating Jew - specially if you advocate equal opportunities for all. The opponents will quickly condemn me for not apparently recognizing that many Jewish people died in the Holocaust to allow all Jewish people to have the current state of Israel (as if that was true).

What does this have anything to do with Palestinians producing cheap labor force while the Jewish class remain the investor-owner class of the society with the full backing of the Israeli government and the backing of the US, British, and French governments to carry it its apartheid of the indigenous people of Palestine.

But I believe that apartheid is not necessary and, in the long term, ineffective. Allow a truly free society in Israel, and allow a new nation to be named, Palestine for the Palestinian people and Israel for Israeli people. Nobody has to live in an apartheid and nobody has to live under conditions of slavery, with little or no rights as an equal citizen. Then prosperity will prosper and we can all win. Right now only the few win, and the masses remain in fear. Fear of terrorism or fear of continuity of injustice and inequality.

Despite my views, sadly and unfortunately segregation and political and economic discrimination continues today in occupied territories and deliberately engineered in order to create economic prosperity for some Jewish people (the big-money investors in particular) while Palestinian people are used as slaves so that the rich stay rich and the poor have to go to work for low wages.

We should not excuse ourselves or the injustice that is going on in Israel as history will judge us harshly.

Shouldn't we all want and ask for equality and justice for all?

He who excuses himself accuses himself.

 
WritersViews.com is a community web site dedicated to writers and friends, our 16,000+ members. Regarded as one of the most professional and well-organized online communities, it offers posting of articles and opinion, group discussions, local meetups, free hosting of your content, free E-Commerce web hosting & merchant account for selling your books, content or commercial writing, free workshops, video chat, polls, job postings, freelance projects, and classified ads, ... AND, it is all FREE.

Rate this Post / Article :

Email this Page to your friend :

Share this Post / Article with your friends :

Other Related Articles :

A Few Good Men and Women. - 1,340 (last 30 days)
Two thousand years of European crimes agains Jews has been conveniently forgotten. - 742 (last 30 days)
12 million people died in the genecide of Nazi's, why we only hear about the 6 million Jews - 496 (last 30 days)
Will there ever be peace? - 355 (last 30 days)

More >>

Other Articles Posted by this Writer : Writer's Portfolio >>

 
 
 
All ideas or comments made are the views of the writers themselves, and not the community organizers or other members and protected by FREEDOM OF SPEECH, recognized as human right under Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights as stated in international human rights law in the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. WritersViews.com does not make any warranties or representations in any way, whatsoever.
posted by: Kate Russell  - 9th, June 2009 at 10:44 am
Most people in the media deplore the Palestinian suicide bombings more than anything than what Israel has done against the Palestinian people. It's horrible on both sides and should not be represented in a biased way as our media does. Thank you for your perspective Hagai as we don't often get a fair and unbiased post like this from the American media, More >>
posted by: Lewis Arnold   - 9th, June 2009 at 11:07 am
I was watching CSPAN during the Israeli 60 years celebrations this year and saw our congressmen and women spend 3 days praising Israel. I was wondering why they are not working to fix our problems in US, such as Social Security, Healthcare, Education, ... then I remembered how much money these US politicians get from the jewish lobby in DC, More >>
posted by: Nick Oualline - 9th, June 2009 at 1:29 pm
Israel has a lot of power in the media since many of the US Corporate CEOs are Jewish and often Israeli lobbyist and member of the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, and because the media never represents both sides fairly and "equally", we all have to witness such horrors against so many, for so long. It is such a shame that both sides, More >>
posted by: Charles Kent- 9th, June 2009 at 9:13 pm
Pelosi said that Carter's views did not reflect that of the Democratic Party. Why can't anybody in our government say anything about Israel? Are we not free in America? I am more pro Israel than I am other governments in that part of the world - but I don't want to be a donkey regurgitating everything that our politicians and media repeats, can we have real freedom in US one day, More >>
posted by: Greg Silverson- 10th, June 2009 at 12:55 am
It is all so screwed up over there. My friends and I went to Israel and we did not feel very good when we went to restaurants and went to the beach. There is a feeling to the place that is very grim and sad and it is hard to feel joyful there. We all felt it and none of us went back there for vacation since, More >>
 
 
 
 
MOST POPULAR POSTS / ARTICLES :
3 things you must do if you want to get a job in the next 90 days, Guide - by: Fiona Harper - 7,648 (last 30 days)
Weekend Getaways: Break away, and have fun, on a low budget? - by: Ava Thomas - 7,042 (last 30 days)
Greatest American Sports Story: Determination, Glory, Heartbreak - by: Michael Daniel - 6,890 (last 30 days)
Energy Technology: Four million new high-paying jobs in the next 6 years! - by: Ashley Jones - 6,719 (last 30 days)
Mortgage foreclosures, credit cards, student loans, stocks, what next? - by: Grace Tayler - 5,011 (last 30 days)
Insomnia: Causes & Treatment - by: Chantelle Bell - 4,961 (last 30 days)
President Barak Obama policies - by: Ryan Hogan - 2,872 (last 30 days)
Superfoods: Love your body - by: Mary Ireland - 2,685 (last 30 days)
Whose pain? and Whose gain? - by: Leila Hamadani - 2,374 (last 30 days)
The New American Century ! - by: Emily Sumner - 1,649 (last 30 days)
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
© Copyright 2009. All rights reserved and enforced regularly by monitoring illegal reproductions and copyright infringements.
Violating our copyrights can make you liable for up to $150,000 in court-awarded damages.
No information on this site may be copied or republished in any way, whatsoever, without express written consent.
 
Every day, people just like you, come to WritersViews.com web site to read or share ideas and comments. WritersViews.com community organizers and members can not make any representations or claims as to the validity, correctness, currency, completeness or timeliness of the Information, Ideas, or Comments posted in this web site, or at any links to external site. All ideas or comments made are the views of the writers themselves, and not the community organizers or other members and protected by FREEDOM OF SPEECH, recognized as human right under Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights as stated in international human rights law in the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. WritersViews.com does not make any warranties or representations in any way, whatsoever. The reader assumes sole responsibility for the selection and use of or reliance on the Information contained in this web site or the members' area, and full responsibility for any or all interaction with other members.